David C Cook COVID-19 Response

May I Autograph Your Liver?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Materials Needed:

  • Internet access

In early 2018, Simon Bramhall—a surgeon from the city of Birmingham in England—got in trouble for taking a little too much pride in his work.

In 2013, he performed liver transplants on two different patients. The problem is what he did after the organs were in place. After the patients’ livers had been transplanted, Mr. Bramhall used a special machine to burn his initials into the livers. 

If you’re wondering how it turned out, Mr. Bramhall* didn’t land in jail for initialing livers. But he had to pay a $13,000 fine and do 120 hours of community service . . . after he’d already lost his job at the hospital. In other words, he paid a steep price.

In July of this year, the justice who sentenced Mr. Bramhall decided she had not given the surgeon enough punishment for his actions.

Read the following paragraphs from the article out loud to your students:
Surgeon who burned initials onto patients’ livers faces fresh tribunal after GMC complaint 

“The Medical Practitioners Tribunal (MPT) originally gave Simon Bramhall a five-month suspension but in an appeal on Tuesday, the General Medical Council (GMC) complained this was an ‘insufficient’ punishment.

Mrs. Justice Collins Rice said the previous tribunal – which took place last year – did not ‘put its finger on precisely what was and was not wrong’ with Bramhall’s conduct.”

  • Why do you think Mr. Bramhall signed the livers of his patients? (It was probably a form of pride. He seems to have been more focused on his own skill in surgery than on his role of helping patients.)

News reports indicate that Mr. Bramhall was very good at his job. It’s okay to be proud of something that you’re good at. Suppose someone had asked, “Mr. Bramhall, are you good at surgery?” It would have been truthful for him to say “yes.” He helped a lot of patients heal, and that’s wonderful!

Pride becomes a problem when we stop focusing on how we can use our talents to serve God and people, and start focusing on ourselves instead. “What’s in it for me?” “How can I get people to notice me?” Instead of helping others, I’m only considering how my talents benefit myself. 

  • How do you think that idea applies to Mr. Bramhall? (Apparently, he forgot that his role was to help people heal. Instead, he thought his skills as a surgeon made him so amazing that he should autograph the inside of his patients’ bodies.)

Mr. Bramhall couldn’t resist signing his patients’ livers out of pride . . .  and in the end, he paid a steep price.

Today, we’re going to look at some other people who paid a high price for pride. Our Bible story is about a group of people who were proud of their building abilities. But instead of using their skills to build homes for others, they tried constructing a monument to themselves . . . with dire consequences.

*Surgeons are generally called “Mister” (rather than “Doctor”) in the United Kingdom.

Looking for Steps 2 & 3?

You can find Steps 2 and 3 in your teacher’s guide. To purchase a teacher’s guide, please visit: Bible-in-Life or Echoes.

Materials Needed:

  • Ruled paper
  • Pens/pencils
  • Optional: Sample encouragement note

Spread the word

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share This